Commonly-asked Magic questions on reddit
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-30 21:45:43
What are your house rules?
Count so far: 36
General questions
Specific house rules
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-26 01:57:36
What if ______ could be a commander?
Planeswalkers
Count so far: 31
Other things
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-26 01:47:08
Sell me...
Count so far: 197
Non-specific, including "unique", and "fun" commanders
- 2019-01-29 - 361 posts - Who's your favorite commander?
- 2018-12-19 - 42 posts - Looking for my next commander and want some help from you awesome people! Sell me on some fun, but really competitive commanders!
- 2018-06-12 - 48 posts - Sell me on your favorite commander/deck!
- 2018-06-10 - 27 posts - Looking to build a more funky/casual/unique deck, looking for recommendations! Sell me on your oddball deck ^_^
- 2018-06-04 - 20 posts - Be a good salesman and sell me on my next deck!
- 2018-06-04 - 255 posts - Tell me about your Commanders that play differently every time.
- 2018-04-26 - 21 posts - Sell me on your commander
- 2018-04-12 - 46 posts - Help a Modern Spike choose a reasonable 70% Commander
- 2017-12-16 - 43 posts - Sell me your untraditional, wacky or otherwise special commander!
- 2017-12-08 - 16 posts - Sell me on a commander
- 2017-12-05 - 40 posts - Sell me into playing your commander!
- 2017-11-06 - 55 posts - Sell me my next commander please!
- 2017-10-29 - 111 posts - What's your favorite Commander with a unique alternative wincon?
- 2017-10-24 - 22 posts - Looking to build something new, sell me on your colour combo/commander.
- 2017-08-08 - 11 posts - Sell me a commander I wouldn't choose myself
- 2017-07-20 - 12 posts - Sell me on your commander
- 2017-07-05 - 58 posts - I'm stuck deciding what commander I should play
- 2017-06-08 - 475 posts - Who are your favorite Commander and why?
- 2017-05-27 - 63 posts - Looking for a new deck, sell me your commander!
- 2017-05-22 - 156 posts - Sell me on your favourite commander(s)
- 2017-05-08 - 26 posts - Sell me on your uncommon commander.
- 2017-04-05 - 62 posts - Who is your go-to fun commander?
- 2017-03-06 - 155 posts - Sell me your reliable multiplayer commander
- 2017-02-16 - 380 posts - Sell me on your underplayed Commander
- 2017-02-16 - 36 posts - Sell me on your most unique(ly powerful?) commander deck.
- 2017-01-25 - 82 posts - Favorite Commanders and why?
- 2017-01-10 - 168 posts - Looking for my next deck. Sell me on your fav commander please.
- 2016-12-29 - 204 posts - EDH Players of reddit, who is your favorite commander and why?
- 2016-12-15 - 77 posts - What is your favorite commander and why?
- 2016-11-17 - 313 posts - Hey, what's your favorite Commander and why??
- 2016-09-11 - 45 posts - Looking for Commander: Something Fresh and exciting
- 2016-09-08 - 223 posts - Sell Me On Your "Fun" Commander
- 2016-08-22 - 20 posts - Sell me on your commander
- 2016-08-19 - 29 posts - Need suggestions for a new commander / style
- 2016-07-15 - 102 posts - I hate playing "good stuff" decks... but i like being competitive. Sell me on a commander
- 2016-05-31 - 12 posts - One last game, sell me a deck.
- 2016-05-15 - 106 posts - Favorite Commander?
- 2016-05-04 - 32 posts - Would appreciate help deciding on a new commander
- 2016-04-10 - 158 posts - Sell me on your commander
- 2016-03-31 - 30 posts - Sell me on your Commander/deck
- 2016-02-16 - 23 posts - Sell me a new commander
- 2016-01-17 - 38 posts - Help Broadening My EDH Horizion
- 2016-01-14 - 170 posts - What's your favorite commander that more people should play?
- 2015-12-08 - 193 posts - What's your favorite commander to play?
- 2015-12-03 - 85 posts - Help me to choose a new unusual and not expected general, please!
- 2015-11-26 - 91 posts - Sell me on a new commander for mostly multiplayer games.
- 2015-11-04 - 48 posts - Commanders that encourage strange and unique strategies.
- 2015-10-13 - 98 posts - Sell me on a new Commander!
- 2015-09-25 - 21 posts - Help me get out of my comfort zone.
- 2015-09-04 - 37 posts - Sell Me On Your Commander!
- 2015-08-30 - 27 posts - So I've been stuck in a rut and can't decide on a new Commander. Sell me on one that's fun.
- 2015-08-11 - 16 posts - Sell me a new commander/deck style
- 2015-07-05 - 112 posts - ... /r/EDH, sell me on a deck I can have fun with while loosing.
- 2015-06-13 - 35 posts - Sell me on General
- 2015-03-11 - 35 posts - Convince me to play your commander!!
- 2015-03-02 - 15 posts - "Sell" me my next Commander
- 2015-02-09 - 45 posts - Sell me your deck!
- 2015-01-07 - 163 posts - Sell me your commander!
Specific colour requirements
Mono-coloured
Non-specific
Mono White
Mono Blue
Mono Black
Mono Red
Mono Green
Two colour
Non-specific
UW (Azorius)
UB (Dimir)
BR (Rakdos)
RG (Gruul)
GW (Selesnya)
UR (Izzet)
UB (Simic)
BW (Orzhov)
BG (Golgari)
WR (Boros)
Three colour
Non-specific
WUB (Esper)
UBR (Grixis)
WGR (Naya)
WBR (Mardu)
BUG (Sultai)
RUG (Temur)
GBW (Abzan)
Excluding specific colours
Miscellaneous (including but not limited to one or more colours)
Specific themes or strategies
Artifact focused
Budget
Control
Stax
Voltron
Miscellaneous
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-26 01:17:15
Proxies in EDH
Discussions about whether proxies are okay with people/groups
Count so far: 78
- 2019-04-09 - 250 posts - Playing with proxies?
- 2019-04-09 - 101 posts - Regarding Proxies
- 2019-03-11 - 30 posts - What is the rules for Proxies in your meta?
- 2019-02-24 - 31 posts - Proxies
- 2019-02-12 - 45 posts - Proxies??
- 2019-02-07 - 10 posts - Proxy??? Y/N
- 2019-01-31 - 255 posts - Proxy for more expensive cards when already owning one?
- 2019-01-02 - 138 posts - How Do You Feel About Proxies?
- 2018-12-23 - 97 posts - 50% Proxies: Am I Overreacting?
- 2018-12-19 - 201 posts - Is it okay to Proxy OG Duals?
- 2018-12-18 - 71 posts - EDH w/ proxies
- 2018-12-10 - 20 posts - Where would you draw the line?
- 2018-11-10 - 141 posts - When do proxies become too ridiculous?
- 2018-10-15 - 112 posts - My unpopular opinion
- 2018-09-05 - 24 posts - How would you feel about a new/returning player (no collection) proxying a deck?
- 2018-08-09 - 19 posts - Having the Proxy Discussion with Your Playgroup
- 2018-08-09 - 23 posts - Gold Bordered Cards
- 2018-07-14 - 156 posts - [Discussion] Proxies for card you own, In Kitchen Table.
- 2018-06-10 - 173 posts - What are your personal thoughts on proxies, and where do you draw the line?
- 2018-05-31 - 47 posts - Proxies in EDH
- 2018-05-27 - 137 posts - Why are some players opposed to playing against proxy cards in non tournament Commander games?
- 2018-05-22 - 69 posts - How does everyone feel about proxies?
- 2018-05-18 - 32 posts - Thoughts on proxied cards.
- 2018-04-30 - 83 posts - Gold-borders as proxies
- 2018-04-17 - 10 posts - Kinda of a noob question, but why are the rules for using proxies in Commander events?
- 2018-04-15 - 160 posts - Proxies - Summary and exteneded discussion
- 2018-04-14 - 505 posts - Ok, I get the proxy issue now.
- 2018-04-13 - 24 posts - [GatheringMagic / CommanderRuminations] Proxies and Playgroups
- 2018-04-13 - 230 posts - Proxy problem in the play group
- 2018-04-10 - 17 posts - How do you feel about "higher quality proxies" like Collector's Edition, World Championship Cards... etc..?
- 2018-04-09 - 260 posts - A Discussion about Proxies in EDH
- 2018-03-28 - 48 posts - Edh proxies?
- 2018-02-26 - 25 posts - Is it okay to proxy dual lands if you have a real copy of the land?
- 2018-02-26 - 90 posts - What is your opinion of people using Proxy's in their decks as, Dual lands, which they do not own, win cons, which they do not own, and other expensive cards they do not own.
- 2018-02-26 - 49 posts - Proxies, yay or nay, regardless they always start a fight somehow.
- 2018-02-17 - 103 posts - Morality of Proxies
- 2017-12-07 - 35 posts - Do you think it is ok to use a proxy (in a very limited way described below)
- 2017-09-10 - 42 posts - About Proxies.
- 2017-07-05 - 133 posts - Opinions on proxying?
- 2017-06-14 - 18 posts - Proxy Foils / in EDH
- 2017-05-21 - 66 posts - What is the general consensus on proxies?
- 2017-03-20 - 35 posts - Controversial Opinion: I'm starting to think I'm ok with proxies in under powered theme decks OR When do you think they will reprint Crucible of Worlds?
- 2017-03-17 - 75 posts - Gold-Bordered Cards: Aye or Nay?
- 2017-03-15 - 18 posts - Conflicted About Proxies
- 2017-02-23 - 39 posts - How does your playgroup feel about fake(high quality proxy) cards?
- 2017-02-06 - 219 posts - your playgroups position on proxies
- 2016-10-31 - 110 posts - Towards a Better Proxy Policy (An Effortpost)
- 2016-10-25 - 25 posts - What is your opinion on Proxies in casual eDH?
- 2016-10-22 - 48 posts - Good looking proxies in EDH?
- 2016-10-14 - 12 posts - House rules for proxies?
- 2016-06-07 - 146 posts - Attended an EDH sitdown last night and I was wondering proxies were common?
- 2016-05-08 - 15 posts - How do you feel about proxies in edh
- 2016-04-14 - 252 posts - Where does your local playgroup draw the line on proxies?
- 2016-03-30 - 84 posts - Proxy or Counterfeit? Opinions?
- 2016-03-22 - 41 posts - General Consensus on Proxies when you have one copy of a card?
- 2015-11-30 - 154 posts - The consensus on Proxies?
- 2015-11-13 - 65 posts - A question about proxies
- 2015-11-04 - 23 posts - Dealing with Proxies in playgroup
- 2015-09-20 - 91 posts - Opinion on proxies in EDH?
- 2015-06-05 - 130 posts - The Proxy Bros.
- 2015-02-26 - 94 posts - Proxies, for older, hard to get cards.
- 2015-02-25 - 23 posts - Subreddit vote: Yay or Nay on proxy-ing cards you own.
- 2014-12-21 - 90 posts - Owners of multiple decks! I have a question for you.
- 2014-12-17 - 61 posts - Thoughts on Proxies?
- 2014-11-11 - 35 posts - Proxies in Commander
- 2014-09-07 - 82 posts - How do you proxy?
- 2014-08-18 - 46 posts - What are your playgroups feelings about proxies?
- 2014-04-30 - 25 posts - Proxy thoughts.
- 2014-04-26 - 46 posts - On Proxies - Do You Mind The Pretty Ones?
- 2014-04-14 - 40 posts - Help with proxies ruining the game?
- 2014-03-27 - 88 posts - EDH Proxies: How far is too far?
- 2014-02-28 - 49 posts - Would you allow owned-proxy decks in your play group?
- 2013-11-21 - 153 posts - Informal Poll: Proxy etiquette
- 2013-11-11 - 46 posts - Proxies: Your Feels?
- 2013-09-02 - 36 posts - What kind of restrictions on proxies or cards does your playgroup have in effect?
- 2013-05-08 - 58 posts - What is /r/EDH's opinion on proxies?
- 2013-04-14 - 19 posts - How do you feel about playing people who proxy EDH decks?
- 2012-07-23 - 62 posts - What is your opinion on Proxies in EDH?
How do people make proxies?
Count so far: 16
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-26 00:57:47
What if all commanders had Partner?
Count so far: 25
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2019-04-26 00:57:37
Budget five colour mana bases
/r/EDH posts
Count so far: 41
Discussions and articles on other sites
Other suggestions
- Do an EDHrec or TappedOut search for five colour decks with price limit to get a sense of what people have done in the past.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last updated: 2018-04-04 04:14:55
What's your favourite basic land art?
Count so far: 31